Homer never explicitly casts the two as lovers 1 2 but they were depicted as lovers in the archaic and classical periods of greek literature, particularly in the works of aeschylus, aeschines and plato. I think the one major difference was that more this is not a twilightlike book. Achilles and patroclus are so emotionally close that patroclus. Jun 18, 2017 achilles, knowing these paths, chose the latter and agreed to go to troy under the mycenaean king and leader of the greek army agamemnon. This passage suggests the inferiority of patroclus compared to achilles. The reason for this is that the death of the substitute for achilles, patroclus, is stressed in the iliad, whereas it is only vestigial in the odyssey. The project gutenberg ebook of the iliad of homer by homer this ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the iliad and what it means. The relationship between achilles and patroclus is a key element of the myths associated with the trojan war. The grief of achilles over patroclusthe visit of thetis to vulcan and the armour that he made for achilles. Euphorbus, the trojan who first speared him, tries to strip him of achilles armor but is killed by menelaus.
Though the iliad is in many ways a story about achilles, the death of patroclus is a pivotal moment within the epic. They must hold the enemy back and protect patroclus body until achilles arrives. I think the one major difference was that patroclus was a capable warrior in the iliad but while hes less of a fighter here, though he does ok when hes forced into the role. The book is an interpretation of the legend of achilles and patroclus, made famous in the iliad. The grief of achilles over patroclus the visit of thetis to vulcan and the armour that he made for achilles. However, book 9 provides insights into his past, present, and future. Achilles declines to fight but agrees to the exchange of armor, with the understanding that patroclus will fight only long enough to save the ships. If he will not relent, achilles should at least let patroclus take his armor and troops into battle. After returning to the achaean camp, achilles and the myrmidons mourn patroclus, and achilles vents his anger by abusing hectors corpse. A retelling of patroklus death from book xvi of the iliad, heavily inspired by the song of achilles by madeline miller. I do not share the same opinion, and i am glad i am not alone.
Achilles sadness and anger about the loss of his very dear friend is what finally causes him to get over his spat with agamemnon, and back into battle. When patroklos does advise achilleus, it is usually by acting as his conscience. He followed achilles to troy as his brotherinarms, and when achilles refused to fight in order to annoy agamemnon, patroclus appeared in achilles armor at the head of the myrmidons and was slain by hector. Patroclus tells achilles how badly the battle is going and scolds him for his rage. The odyssey, the cypria also spelled kypria, the little iliad the myrmidons by aeschylus the symposium by plato the song of achilles. Shall be laid to waste, nor even by that of achilles, a man far batter than you. Even though patroklos is an important character in the iliad, homer gives little attention to him until the ninth book, and even then, the focus is not on patroklos himself, but on his relationship to achilles. The myrmidons swarm like bees as patroclus sounds the charge and fills them with courage. Aka songs, queer books, achilles and patroclus, greek gods, book. That by your spear this town of the gifted trojans. Murray 1 then was the gathering broken up, and the folk scattered, each man to go to his own ship.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. He vows he will not wash hectors blood off his body until he has buried patroclus. Patroclus replies that achilles anger is too stubborn. Achilles profile of the greek hero of the trojan war. Revisiting the apostrophes to patroclus in iliad 16. Achilles and patroclus grew up together after menoitios gave patroclus to achilles father, peleus. One of the most famous passages in the iliad comes at the start of book 18, when achilles learns that his beloved companion patroclus has been. I encounter a lot of people who raise the characterization of patroclus as this book s achilles heel, saying that the handling of his character is almost an insult to the original story it is based on. This is a crucial book and a turning point because in it zeus sits idly by knowing his son sarpedon will be killed, and achilles friend patroclus is also killed.
Tragically, patroclus is begging for his own death. Achilles directly causes the death of his friend by first refusing to fight, leaving the greeks at a disadvantage, and then poorly advising his friend patroclus to join the other fighters. Aug 04, 2017 the iliad is the oldest surviving work of greek literature, written by homer in the 8th century bc. In the iliad, it is clear that the two heroes have a deep and extremely meaningful friendship, but the evidence. In the iliad, homer describes a deep and meaningful relationship between achilles and patroclus, where achilles is tender toward patroclus but callous and arrogant toward others. When he and achilles are together, before agamemnons ambassadors arrive, patroklos waits for achilles to finish singing before he begins speaking. Hector sees this move, advances, and putting a spear through patroclus belly, kills him. Perhaps the most important relationship in the poem is the intense friendship between achilles and his comrade patroclus. It is an epic poem, with 24 chapters, based on the attack on troy by the mycenaeans. Why the tale of achilles and his lover still has the power. In the iliad, homer describes a deep and meaningful relationship between. The iliad cliffsnotes study guides book summaries, test. He was the son of menoetius, and is most famous as being the dear companion of achilles. On 05 sept 2017 i visited the british museum and photographed some of the gods featured in the iliad and related greek mythology, so i will create a fresh photo album for these.
What was achilless reaction to patrocluss death in the iliad. T hus then did they fight as it were a flaming fire. How does book 9 of the iliad serve to develop achilles s character. This lesson will summarize the events surrounding the heros end, and explain its significance for the epic as a whole. Commander of the myrmidons, achilles is the most powerful hero in the iliad and was said to be invulnerable in all of his body but his heel, where his mother held him when she dipped him in the river styx in an attempt to make him immortal. Through most of the poem achilles s character is developed primarily through conflict and battle. The trojans see the coming myrmidons and believe that achilles has finally come to battle. There is no dramatic character development, but one does see patroklos as a character perpetrates dramatic events and provides a. In the iliad, the two heroes have a deep and meaningful friendship. Character profile for patroclus from the iliad page 1. As they fought on around the benched ship, patroclus, hot tears pouring down his face like a stream of dark water flowing in dusky streaks down the face of a sheer cliff, returned to achilles, leader of men. He filled both hands with dust from off the ground, and poured it over his head, disfiguring his comely face, and letting the refuse settle over his shirt so fair and new. Meanwhile the fleet runner antilochus, who had been sent as messenger, reached achilles, and found him sitting by his tall ships and boding that which was indeed too surely true. Howbeit patroclus, the squire of achilles, might the wellgreaved achaeans not draw forth from amid the darts.
Similarities and differences between the iliad and the movie troy 1057 words 5 pages. A dark cloud of grief fell upon achilles as he listened. All orders are custom made and most ship worldwide within 24 hours. For the first of the three speech formulae, we must turn to the beginning of book 16, before patroclus even heads into battle. Zeus knows that the death of patroclus will force achilles to fight for the greeks achaeansdanaansargives. Patroclus simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Patroclus s spirit visits him in a dream, asking why he has forgotten him. See more ideas about achilles, achilles and patroclus and greek mythology. The iliad is an epic poem in dactylic hexameters, traditionally attributed to homer. Achilles agrees but tells patroclus he should only drive the trojans back from the ships, not follow them to. Book xxii and xxiv discuss the events of hectors death and burial emphasized by achilles actions, while book xxiii provides a transition between the two.
The death of patroclus in the iliad full free lesson. Whether in the context of a tender friendship or military excellence, homer makes their strong connection clear. The friendship of achilles and patroclus is mentioned explicitly in the iliad. Achilles is the quintessentially heroic subject of homers great poem of adventure and war, the iliad. Together, these books emphasize the dilution of achilles rage as is contrasted by the fall of hector and the subsequent fall of troy. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in the iliad, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. The pivotal point of the iliad from achilles perspective is the death of patroclus, occurring after achilles himself refused to fight the trojans in the name of agamemnon. We also see it when patroklos convinces achilleus to let him lead the myrmidons into battle. Similarly, hector s passion to defend troy is shown in book vi, a tender moment in which he visits his wife and child, assuring them that he will return from battle safely. This made achilles so angry, that he refused to rest until he had killed hector, and honored his friends death by solemn burial rites. How does the fact that hector thinks patroclus was sent by achilles to sack troy and kill hector create sympathy for achilles and patroclus. The scene in which achilles immortal horses stand immobile on the field of battle, weeping for the dead patroklos, and zeus asks himself why the gods involved them in the miseries of mortal existence iliad 17. Its exact nature has been a subject of dispute in both the classical period and modern times.
I will soon include some extracts in this facebook page. In fact, one rarely sees patroklos as an individual. The iliad book 16 death of patroclus american literature. He knows the chosen one and hes a boy just like himselfexcept hes golden and perfect, hes the star quidditch player and. The death of patroclus underpins a great deal of achilles actions and emotions toward the trojan war for the rest of the poem. Homer, iliad book 24 theoi classical texts library. Get an answer for what was achilles s reaction to patroclus s death in the iliad. Above all, the iliad presents the tragic yet thrilling reality of humanitys mortality, and as the events unfold, we are ever reminded that our lives are shaped and buffeted by the winds of fate from which even the central character achilles, magnificent warrior that he is, cannot escape. Gif of the song of achilles achilles and patroclus. Anticleias role in the narrative is unimportant, yet her counterparts in the yugoslav tradition are kept even to this day see appendix iii. Set in the trojan war, the tenyear siege of ilium by a coalition of greek states, it tells of the battles and events during the weeks of a quarrel between king agamemnon and the warrior achilles.
Homer, iliad book 18 theoi classical texts library. Although the death of patroclus prompts him to seek reconciliation with agamemnon, it does not alleviate his rage, but instead redirects it toward hector. In the iliad, homer describes a deep and meaningful relationship between achilles and patroclus, where achilles is tender toward patroclus. Good books my books achilles and patroclus daughter of smoke and bone captive prince greek history bubbline greek gods heroes of olympus. Lead forth my martial myrmidons to fight, go save the fleets, and conquer in my right. Priam wept freely for man killing hector, throbbing, crouching before achilles feet as achilles wept himself, now for his father, now for patroclus once again and their sobbing rose and fell throughout the house. Read book 16 death of patroclus of the iliad by homer. The theme of love and friendship in the iliad from litcharts. Achilles tells him he has no reason to grieve, saying that agamemnon s men are repaid for their offenses. Grace sunny kang hist 151 october 10, 2017 comparison between the epic poem the iliad and the film troy the modernday film troy that was released in 2004 was directed by wolfgang petersen, it was influenced by the epic poem, called the iliad which was written by the poet homer. The iliad is about the trojan war, but it is primarily about the war as it is affected by achilles wrath, or anger. The relationship between achilles and patroclus is a key element of the stories associated with the trojan war. At once a scholars homage to the iliad and startlingly original work of art by an incredibly talented new novelist.
Book 16 meanwhile, patroclus goes to achilles tent and begs to be allowed to wear achilles armor if achilles still refuses to rejoin the battle himself. While homers iliad never explicitly stated that achilles and patroclus were lovers, this concept was asserted by some later authors. Achilles is brutal, vain, pitiless and a true hero. Achilles retrieves a special cup and pours libation to zeus praying for patroclus to come back unharmed having gained glory.
During the trojan war, achilles refuses to fight after a quarrel with agamemnon, leader of the greek forces. The song of achilles is a novel by american author madeline miller. It introduces patroclus desperate plea to achilles that he be allowed to wear his armor and enter the fray in his stead 16. After the death of patroclus, achilles will refuse to eat with the other greek warriors, which demonstrates the dissonance between achilles and all other mortal men. Achilles is the main character, and his inaction, or withdrawal from the fighting, is crucial to the plot. Meanwhile, patroclus goes to achilles tent and begs to be allowed to wear achilles armor if achilles still refuses to rejoin the battle himself. When agamemnons agents arrive, patroklos silently mixes drinks, and then both he and achilles work together as equals to prepare a meal for the guests.
He was conquered by zeus will, and the efforts of the brave trojans. Patroclus asks if he can go into battle in achilles place. Patroclus returns to achilles camp, crying with pity for the achaean losses. Phoenixs story of achilles s earlier life includes touching scenes of him as a small child. Him he found in front of his ships with upright horns, boding in his heart the thing that even now was brought to pass. An example can be derived from a passage in book xvi from apollo to patroclus, fall back zeus descended patroclus. Son of the immortal sea nymph thetis and greek hero peleus, achilles is one of the most widely known heroes of myth. Achilles, patroclus and briseis the iliad goes to high school. Achilles was the greatest of the warriors famed for his swiftness on the greek achaean side during the trojan war, directly competing with troys warrior hero hector. The fate of patroclus in the iliad of homer schoolworkhelper. The song of achilles sticks pretty closely to the plot of the iliad. Like most homeric characters, achilles does not develop significantly over the course of the epic. Achilles is tender towards patroclus, while he is callous and arrogant towards others. Book 17 reveals that patroclus was a man greatly beloved by his comrades.
On 05 sept 2017 i visited the british museum and photographed some of the gods featured in the iliad and related greek mythology, so i. Patroclus is cremated on a funeral pyre, and his bones are collected into a golden urn in two layers of fat. Patroclus has fallen, and a fight is raging about his naked body for hector holds his armour. In book 9, achilles will demonstrate his knowledge of xenia by welcoming odysseus, phoenix, and ajax into his tent and serving them a great feast. Achilles tells him he has no reason to grieve, saying that agamemnon s. Achilles is brutal, vain, pitiless and a true hero books. For better or for worse, the homeric epics are a bedrock part of the western literary canon. We get a sense of this from briseiss speech in book 19, when she tells us that patroklos promised to convince achilleus to take her as his lawful wife. Inspired designs on tshirts, posters, stickers, home decor, and more by independent artists and designers from around the world. Achilles cliffsnotes study guides book summaries, test. Madeline millers the song of achilles looks at the iliad from a fresh perspective. Patroclus called out to his men at the top of his voice, myrmidons, followers of achilles son of peleus, be men my friends, fight with might and with main, that we may win glory for the son of peleus, who is far the foremost man at the ships of the argives he, and his close fighting followers. During this time, peleus made patroclus one of achilles henchmen. The achaeans fight to protect their friends body from ignominious treatment while the trojans fight to win greater glory.
What was achilless reaction to patrocluss death in the. In homers iliad, war is depicted as horrible, bloody, and fruitless. Jul 17, 2010 the friendship of achilles and patroclus is mentioned explicitly in the iliad. See the thin relics of their baffled band at the last edge of yon deserted land. The event does not make achilles a more deliberative or selfreflective character. In the iliad, patroclus is a close friend and confidant of achilles, who leads the greeks in war against the trojans. The funeral of patroclus is described in book 23 of the iliad. And overpowered by memory both men gave way to grief. The rest bethought them of supper and of sweet sleep, to take their fill thereof. Feb 16, 2016 achilles, too, has to spend his time in the muck. Achilles and patroclus project gutenberg selfpublishing. The death of patroclus is one of the most powerful scenes in homers iliad.
154 206 236 350 992 141 1453 936 698 1391 1391 1119 1392 1259 297 498 422 421 1444 546 1558 790 629 1344 1309 377 288 239 94 1297 1004